Both/and aesthetics: gender, art and language in Brigid Brophy’s In Transit and Ali Smith’s How to Be Both

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper sets out to read Brigid Brophy’s 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel alongside a more recent example of contemporary women’s writing, How to Be Both (2014) by the Scottish writer Ali Smith. Notwithstanding the paucity of criticism on Brophy’s work, critics agree that her 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel stands out as her most significant, experimental and challenging work – and therefore most egregiously overlooked. Despite the consensus, both personal and critical, of "outsiderdom" attaching to her work, Brophy may be seen as part of a longer tradition of experimentalism within women’s writing, which continues today. Indeed, Brophy’s work bears strong comparison with the post-1970s generation of women writers such as Angela Carter, Jeanette Winterson, Michèle Roberts, and Ali Smith. I will argue that the literary and sexual-political preoccupations of Brophy’s path-breaking novel are in great measure consistent with those that contemporary writers such as Smith are currently exploring. In particular, Brophy’s work anatomises the artificial relationship between sex and gender, the dominance of heterosexual narratives and their relation to pornography, and the ways in which art, music and language mediate concepts of gender. The paper will provide an in-depth comparative analysis of In Transit and How to be Both to show how both writers refuse binary oppositions in a “both/and” writing practice that is simultaneously self-consciously aesthetic and political.
Original languageEnglish
Article number2
Pages (from-to)248–263
Number of pages16
JournalContemporary Women's Writing
Volume12
Issue number2
Early online date2 Feb 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 20 Jul 2018

Fingerprint

Aesthetics
Language
Art
Writer
Novel
Women's Writing
Women Writers
Binary Opposition
Comparative Analysis
Criticism
Sexual
Art music
Pornography
Writing Practices
1970s
Experimentalism
Artificial
Angela Carter

Keywords

  • Contemporary women's writing
  • Brigid Brophy
  • Ali Smith
  • gender identity
  • gender and language
  • both/and aesthetics

Cite this

@article{3db214603103413f9392bde05d2d64f5,
title = "Both/and aesthetics: gender, art and language in Brigid Brophy’s In Transit and Ali Smith’s How to Be Both",
abstract = "This paper sets out to read Brigid Brophy’s 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel alongside a more recent example of contemporary women’s writing, How to Be Both (2014) by the Scottish writer Ali Smith. Notwithstanding the paucity of criticism on Brophy’s work, critics agree that her 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel stands out as her most significant, experimental and challenging work – and therefore most egregiously overlooked. Despite the consensus, both personal and critical, of {"}outsiderdom{"} attaching to her work, Brophy may be seen as part of a longer tradition of experimentalism within women’s writing, which continues today. Indeed, Brophy’s work bears strong comparison with the post-1970s generation of women writers such as Angela Carter, Jeanette Winterson, Mich{\`e}le Roberts, and Ali Smith. I will argue that the literary and sexual-political preoccupations of Brophy’s path-breaking novel are in great measure consistent with those that contemporary writers such as Smith are currently exploring. In particular, Brophy’s work anatomises the artificial relationship between sex and gender, the dominance of heterosexual narratives and their relation to pornography, and the ways in which art, music and language mediate concepts of gender. The paper will provide an in-depth comparative analysis of In Transit and How to be Both to show how both writers refuse binary oppositions in a “both/and” writing practice that is simultaneously self-consciously aesthetic and political.",
keywords = "Contemporary women's writing, Brigid Brophy, Ali Smith, gender identity, gender and language, both/and aesthetics",
author = "Sonya Andermahr",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
day = "20",
doi = "10.1093/cww/vpy001",
language = "English",
volume = "12",
pages = "248–263",
journal = "Contemporary Women's Writing",
issn = "1754-1484",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "2",

}

Both/and aesthetics: gender, art and language in Brigid Brophy’s In Transit and Ali Smith’s How to Be Both. / Andermahr, Sonya.

In: Contemporary Women's Writing, Vol. 12, No. 2, 2, 20.07.2018, p. 248–263.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Both/and aesthetics: gender, art and language in Brigid Brophy’s In Transit and Ali Smith’s How to Be Both

AU - Andermahr, Sonya

PY - 2018/7/20

Y1 - 2018/7/20

N2 - This paper sets out to read Brigid Brophy’s 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel alongside a more recent example of contemporary women’s writing, How to Be Both (2014) by the Scottish writer Ali Smith. Notwithstanding the paucity of criticism on Brophy’s work, critics agree that her 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel stands out as her most significant, experimental and challenging work – and therefore most egregiously overlooked. Despite the consensus, both personal and critical, of "outsiderdom" attaching to her work, Brophy may be seen as part of a longer tradition of experimentalism within women’s writing, which continues today. Indeed, Brophy’s work bears strong comparison with the post-1970s generation of women writers such as Angela Carter, Jeanette Winterson, Michèle Roberts, and Ali Smith. I will argue that the literary and sexual-political preoccupations of Brophy’s path-breaking novel are in great measure consistent with those that contemporary writers such as Smith are currently exploring. In particular, Brophy’s work anatomises the artificial relationship between sex and gender, the dominance of heterosexual narratives and their relation to pornography, and the ways in which art, music and language mediate concepts of gender. The paper will provide an in-depth comparative analysis of In Transit and How to be Both to show how both writers refuse binary oppositions in a “both/and” writing practice that is simultaneously self-consciously aesthetic and political.

AB - This paper sets out to read Brigid Brophy’s 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel alongside a more recent example of contemporary women’s writing, How to Be Both (2014) by the Scottish writer Ali Smith. Notwithstanding the paucity of criticism on Brophy’s work, critics agree that her 1969 novel In Transit: An Heroi-cyclic Novel stands out as her most significant, experimental and challenging work – and therefore most egregiously overlooked. Despite the consensus, both personal and critical, of "outsiderdom" attaching to her work, Brophy may be seen as part of a longer tradition of experimentalism within women’s writing, which continues today. Indeed, Brophy’s work bears strong comparison with the post-1970s generation of women writers such as Angela Carter, Jeanette Winterson, Michèle Roberts, and Ali Smith. I will argue that the literary and sexual-political preoccupations of Brophy’s path-breaking novel are in great measure consistent with those that contemporary writers such as Smith are currently exploring. In particular, Brophy’s work anatomises the artificial relationship between sex and gender, the dominance of heterosexual narratives and their relation to pornography, and the ways in which art, music and language mediate concepts of gender. The paper will provide an in-depth comparative analysis of In Transit and How to be Both to show how both writers refuse binary oppositions in a “both/and” writing practice that is simultaneously self-consciously aesthetic and political.

KW - Contemporary women's writing

KW - Brigid Brophy

KW - Ali Smith

KW - gender identity

KW - gender and language

KW - both/and aesthetics

U2 - 10.1093/cww/vpy001

DO - 10.1093/cww/vpy001

M3 - Article

VL - 12

SP - 248

EP - 263

JO - Contemporary Women's Writing

JF - Contemporary Women's Writing

SN - 1754-1484

IS - 2

M1 - 2

ER -