Multi-criteria assessment of the appropriateness of a cooking technology: a case study of the Logone Valley

Mentore Vaccari, Francesca Vitali, Terry L Tudor

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    The choice of fuel for cooking, particularly in rural areas, can lead to significant socio-economic and environmental impacts amongst households. Using the Logone Valley on the border between Chad and Cameroon as the case study region, this study sought to evaluate appropriate cooking technologies for the case study region. Several alternatives to traditional three-stone fire were evaluated, including the: ceramic stove, Centrafricain stove, parabolic solar cooker, biodigester, LPG stove, and mlc rice husk stove. Four main clusters were investigated, structuring quantifiable indicators for financial, environmental, social and health related impacts of the use of a certain energy technology. The findings suggest that the Centrafricain stove alone or in combination with the mlc stove, was the most appropriate cooking technology for use in the case study region. These technologies were more appropriate than the traditional cooking system of the three stone fire. The use of four clusters of criteria, within a weighted system, coupled with the views of users, experts and literature, as well as the scope of the criteria employed enabled a reliable and valid approach to understanding the most appropriate cooking technology to recommend.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)66-75
    Number of pages10
    JournalEnergy Policy
    Volume109
    Early online date30 Jun 2017
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2017

    Fingerprint

    valley
    solar cooker
    economic impact
    ceramics
    stove
    rural area
    environmental impact
    rice
    stone

    Keywords

    • Appropriate technology
    • MCA
    • cook stove
    • three-stone fire
    • wood

    Cite this

    @article{1a66285765fe4f0cbb5e45715a314469,
    title = "Multi-criteria assessment of the appropriateness of a cooking technology: a case study of the Logone Valley",
    abstract = "The choice of fuel for cooking, particularly in rural areas, can lead to significant socio-economic and environmental impacts amongst households. Using the Logone Valley on the border between Chad and Cameroon as the case study region, this study sought to evaluate appropriate cooking technologies for the case study region. Several alternatives to traditional three-stone fire were evaluated, including the: ceramic stove, Centrafricain stove, parabolic solar cooker, biodigester, LPG stove, and mlc rice husk stove. Four main clusters were investigated, structuring quantifiable indicators for financial, environmental, social and health related impacts of the use of a certain energy technology. The findings suggest that the Centrafricain stove alone or in combination with the mlc stove, was the most appropriate cooking technology for use in the case study region. These technologies were more appropriate than the traditional cooking system of the three stone fire. The use of four clusters of criteria, within a weighted system, coupled with the views of users, experts and literature, as well as the scope of the criteria employed enabled a reliable and valid approach to understanding the most appropriate cooking technology to recommend.",
    keywords = "Appropriate technology, MCA, cook stove, three-stone fire, wood",
    author = "Mentore Vaccari and Francesca Vitali and Tudor, {Terry L}",
    year = "2017",
    month = "10",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1016/j.enpol.2017.06.052",
    language = "English",
    volume = "109",
    pages = "66--75",
    journal = "Energy Policy",
    issn = "0301-4215",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    Multi-criteria assessment of the appropriateness of a cooking technology: a case study of the Logone Valley. / Vaccari, Mentore; Vitali, Francesca; Tudor, Terry L.

    In: Energy Policy, Vol. 109, 01.10.2017, p. 66-75.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Multi-criteria assessment of the appropriateness of a cooking technology: a case study of the Logone Valley

    AU - Vaccari, Mentore

    AU - Vitali, Francesca

    AU - Tudor, Terry L

    PY - 2017/10/1

    Y1 - 2017/10/1

    N2 - The choice of fuel for cooking, particularly in rural areas, can lead to significant socio-economic and environmental impacts amongst households. Using the Logone Valley on the border between Chad and Cameroon as the case study region, this study sought to evaluate appropriate cooking technologies for the case study region. Several alternatives to traditional three-stone fire were evaluated, including the: ceramic stove, Centrafricain stove, parabolic solar cooker, biodigester, LPG stove, and mlc rice husk stove. Four main clusters were investigated, structuring quantifiable indicators for financial, environmental, social and health related impacts of the use of a certain energy technology. The findings suggest that the Centrafricain stove alone or in combination with the mlc stove, was the most appropriate cooking technology for use in the case study region. These technologies were more appropriate than the traditional cooking system of the three stone fire. The use of four clusters of criteria, within a weighted system, coupled with the views of users, experts and literature, as well as the scope of the criteria employed enabled a reliable and valid approach to understanding the most appropriate cooking technology to recommend.

    AB - The choice of fuel for cooking, particularly in rural areas, can lead to significant socio-economic and environmental impacts amongst households. Using the Logone Valley on the border between Chad and Cameroon as the case study region, this study sought to evaluate appropriate cooking technologies for the case study region. Several alternatives to traditional three-stone fire were evaluated, including the: ceramic stove, Centrafricain stove, parabolic solar cooker, biodigester, LPG stove, and mlc rice husk stove. Four main clusters were investigated, structuring quantifiable indicators for financial, environmental, social and health related impacts of the use of a certain energy technology. The findings suggest that the Centrafricain stove alone or in combination with the mlc stove, was the most appropriate cooking technology for use in the case study region. These technologies were more appropriate than the traditional cooking system of the three stone fire. The use of four clusters of criteria, within a weighted system, coupled with the views of users, experts and literature, as well as the scope of the criteria employed enabled a reliable and valid approach to understanding the most appropriate cooking technology to recommend.

    KW - Appropriate technology

    KW - MCA

    KW - cook stove

    KW - three-stone fire

    KW - wood

    U2 - 10.1016/j.enpol.2017.06.052

    DO - 10.1016/j.enpol.2017.06.052

    M3 - Article

    VL - 109

    SP - 66

    EP - 75

    JO - Energy Policy

    JF - Energy Policy

    SN - 0301-4215

    ER -