Not only academically oriented, but supportive and friendly. A comparative study of students' idea of a good school in three European countries

Valentina Grion, Cristina Devecchi, Séverine Colinet

Research output: Contribution to conference typesPaperResearch

Abstract

Among the main policy objectives recently re-affirmed by the European Community’s Horizon 2020 and Erasmus+ are the renewed European cooperation in the youth field and the emphasis on developing social capital and citizenship and participation. Indeed, the need to give young people a more significant role in decision-making processes, in particular in school contexts, has been acknowledged by authors although ‘in many aspects of education and social provision, the child’s voice remains absent’ (Sargeant, 2012: 1). Therefore, we need ‘more productive approaches to assessment and accountability’ (Stobart 2008, p. 89) which afford a more significant role to stakeholders inside school communities (Grion and Cook-Sather, 2013). In this context, the aim of this paper is to build a new concept of school quality, drawing from how pupils in England, Italy and France answered the question ‘what does make a good school?’. Qualitative data was collected by direct consultation with pupils through an open ended questionnaire. Pupils aged 11-15 (France (n= 130), England (n= 146), and Italy (n= 145)) took part in the study. Data was analysed by researchers in each of the three countries using a bottom-up approach, consisting of individual researcher’s initial coding, collaborative discussions on the main themes arising from the content analysis. The main finding show pupils have a shared idea of what “a good school” is despite their different national school contexts and systems. Two main dimensions were identified as representing the core of students’ views about the features of a ‘good’ school. The first is that pupils share similar views about the features of a good teacher. The second is that a ‘good’ school is one where teaching and learning is appropriate and more practice-focused; where the climate is friendly, supportive and safe; and, where the physical environment is aesthetically pleasing. This paper discusses the findings by drawing from diverse models of understanding the features of a good school. Clearly, for young people academic features are important but not sufficient to define the complexity of their experience and expectations.

Conference

ConferenceBritish Educational Research Association Conference
Period24/09/1424/09/14
Internet address

Fingerprint

pupil
school
student
Italy
France
European cooperation
decision-making process
social capital
coding
content analysis
citizenship
stakeholder
climate
responsibility
participation
questionnaire
Teaching
teacher
learning
community

Keywords

  • Student voice
  • comparative education
  • school improvement

Cite this

Grion, V., Devecchi, C., & Colinet, S. (2014). Not only academically oriented, but supportive and friendly. A comparative study of students' idea of a good school in three European countries. Paper presented at British Educational Research Association Conference, .
Grion, Valentina ; Devecchi, Cristina ; Colinet, Séverine. / Not only academically oriented, but supportive and friendly. A comparative study of students' idea of a good school in three European countries. Paper presented at British Educational Research Association Conference, .
@conference{40b58866b5c94324aac19cf90327bf02,
title = "Not only academically oriented, but supportive and friendly. A comparative study of students' idea of a good school in three European countries",
abstract = "Among the main policy objectives recently re-affirmed by the European Community’s Horizon 2020 and Erasmus+ are the renewed European cooperation in the youth field and the emphasis on developing social capital and citizenship and participation. Indeed, the need to give young people a more significant role in decision-making processes, in particular in school contexts, has been acknowledged by authors although ‘in many aspects of education and social provision, the child’s voice remains absent’ (Sargeant, 2012: 1). Therefore, we need ‘more productive approaches to assessment and accountability’ (Stobart 2008, p. 89) which afford a more significant role to stakeholders inside school communities (Grion and Cook-Sather, 2013). In this context, the aim of this paper is to build a new concept of school quality, drawing from how pupils in England, Italy and France answered the question ‘what does make a good school?’. Qualitative data was collected by direct consultation with pupils through an open ended questionnaire. Pupils aged 11-15 (France (n= 130), England (n= 146), and Italy (n= 145)) took part in the study. Data was analysed by researchers in each of the three countries using a bottom-up approach, consisting of individual researcher’s initial coding, collaborative discussions on the main themes arising from the content analysis. The main finding show pupils have a shared idea of what “a good school” is despite their different national school contexts and systems. Two main dimensions were identified as representing the core of students’ views about the features of a ‘good’ school. The first is that pupils share similar views about the features of a good teacher. The second is that a ‘good’ school is one where teaching and learning is appropriate and more practice-focused; where the climate is friendly, supportive and safe; and, where the physical environment is aesthetically pleasing. This paper discusses the findings by drawing from diverse models of understanding the features of a good school. Clearly, for young people academic features are important but not sufficient to define the complexity of their experience and expectations.",
keywords = "Student voice, comparative education, school improvement",
author = "Valentina Grion and Cristina Devecchi and S{\'e}verine Colinet",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
day = "24",
language = "English",
note = "British Educational Research Association Conference ; Conference date: 24-09-2014 Through 24-09-2014",
url = "https://www.bera.ac.uk/conference-archive/annual-conference-2014, http://www.beraconference.co.uk/2009/, https://www.bera.ac.uk/beraconference-2016",

}

Grion, V, Devecchi, C & Colinet, S 2014, 'Not only academically oriented, but supportive and friendly. A comparative study of students' idea of a good school in three European countries' Paper presented at British Educational Research Association Conference, 24/09/14 - 24/09/14, .

Not only academically oriented, but supportive and friendly. A comparative study of students' idea of a good school in three European countries. / Grion, Valentina; Devecchi, Cristina; Colinet, Séverine.

2014. Paper presented at British Educational Research Association Conference, .

Research output: Contribution to conference typesPaperResearch

TY - CONF

T1 - Not only academically oriented, but supportive and friendly. A comparative study of students' idea of a good school in three European countries

AU - Grion, Valentina

AU - Devecchi, Cristina

AU - Colinet, Séverine

PY - 2014/9/24

Y1 - 2014/9/24

N2 - Among the main policy objectives recently re-affirmed by the European Community’s Horizon 2020 and Erasmus+ are the renewed European cooperation in the youth field and the emphasis on developing social capital and citizenship and participation. Indeed, the need to give young people a more significant role in decision-making processes, in particular in school contexts, has been acknowledged by authors although ‘in many aspects of education and social provision, the child’s voice remains absent’ (Sargeant, 2012: 1). Therefore, we need ‘more productive approaches to assessment and accountability’ (Stobart 2008, p. 89) which afford a more significant role to stakeholders inside school communities (Grion and Cook-Sather, 2013). In this context, the aim of this paper is to build a new concept of school quality, drawing from how pupils in England, Italy and France answered the question ‘what does make a good school?’. Qualitative data was collected by direct consultation with pupils through an open ended questionnaire. Pupils aged 11-15 (France (n= 130), England (n= 146), and Italy (n= 145)) took part in the study. Data was analysed by researchers in each of the three countries using a bottom-up approach, consisting of individual researcher’s initial coding, collaborative discussions on the main themes arising from the content analysis. The main finding show pupils have a shared idea of what “a good school” is despite their different national school contexts and systems. Two main dimensions were identified as representing the core of students’ views about the features of a ‘good’ school. The first is that pupils share similar views about the features of a good teacher. The second is that a ‘good’ school is one where teaching and learning is appropriate and more practice-focused; where the climate is friendly, supportive and safe; and, where the physical environment is aesthetically pleasing. This paper discusses the findings by drawing from diverse models of understanding the features of a good school. Clearly, for young people academic features are important but not sufficient to define the complexity of their experience and expectations.

AB - Among the main policy objectives recently re-affirmed by the European Community’s Horizon 2020 and Erasmus+ are the renewed European cooperation in the youth field and the emphasis on developing social capital and citizenship and participation. Indeed, the need to give young people a more significant role in decision-making processes, in particular in school contexts, has been acknowledged by authors although ‘in many aspects of education and social provision, the child’s voice remains absent’ (Sargeant, 2012: 1). Therefore, we need ‘more productive approaches to assessment and accountability’ (Stobart 2008, p. 89) which afford a more significant role to stakeholders inside school communities (Grion and Cook-Sather, 2013). In this context, the aim of this paper is to build a new concept of school quality, drawing from how pupils in England, Italy and France answered the question ‘what does make a good school?’. Qualitative data was collected by direct consultation with pupils through an open ended questionnaire. Pupils aged 11-15 (France (n= 130), England (n= 146), and Italy (n= 145)) took part in the study. Data was analysed by researchers in each of the three countries using a bottom-up approach, consisting of individual researcher’s initial coding, collaborative discussions on the main themes arising from the content analysis. The main finding show pupils have a shared idea of what “a good school” is despite their different national school contexts and systems. Two main dimensions were identified as representing the core of students’ views about the features of a ‘good’ school. The first is that pupils share similar views about the features of a good teacher. The second is that a ‘good’ school is one where teaching and learning is appropriate and more practice-focused; where the climate is friendly, supportive and safe; and, where the physical environment is aesthetically pleasing. This paper discusses the findings by drawing from diverse models of understanding the features of a good school. Clearly, for young people academic features are important but not sufficient to define the complexity of their experience and expectations.

KW - Student voice

KW - comparative education

KW - school improvement

UR - https://www.bera.ac.uk/conference-archive/annual-conference-2014

M3 - Paper

ER -