The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield

Janet M Wilson, Sarah Ailwood (Editor), Melinda Harvey (Editor)

Research output: Contribution to Book/Report typesChapterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This essay is situated in relation to the critical commonplace that the contrasting literary modes and prose styles of Frank Sargeson and Katherine Mansfield -- of hard-edged realist writing and the miniaturist ‘subjectivist’ writing of impressionism -- laid the foundation for the two traditions in New Zealand prose. I suggest that significant similarities can be found in the writers' artistic orientation, traceable to their critique of colonial culture and society: namely, an aesthetics of fragmentation, resistance to normative gender constructions of colonial society and their use of symbolic modes of representation. Furthermore, I argue that Mansfield can be traced as an intertextual presence in Sargeson’s work, alongside an implied gendered critique of her female voice, values and attitudes, and that he developed his repertoire by adapting her techniques of impressionism and impersonation to his ambivalently gendered viewpoint in order to nuance masculine vulnerability and unrequited love. This specific influence of Mansfield upon Sargeson will be illustrated with reference to his story, ‘A Man and his Wife’ (1939), in which I suggest he surreptitiously draws on Mansfield’s last story, ‘The Canary’ (1923), ‘writing back’ in a rural colonial context and voice to her metropolitan discourse.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationKatherine Mansfield and Literary Influence
Place of PublicationEdinburgh
PublisherEdinburgh University Press
Pages207-218
Number of pages272
ISBN (Print)9780748694419
Publication statusPublished - 22 Jun 2015

Fingerprint

Katherine Mansfield
Burden
Impressionism
Colonies
Miniaturist
Discourse
Wives
Colonial Society
Prose
Aesthetics
Metropolitan
Fragmentation
Commonplaces
New Zealand
Repertoire
Masculine
Prose Style
Writer
Vulnerability
Realist

Keywords

  • Katherine Mansfield
  • Frank Sargeson
  • New Zealand cultural nationalism
  • homophobic
  • intertextual
  • the feminine tradition
  • 'The Canary'
  • 'A Man and his Wife'

Cite this

Wilson, J. M., Ailwood, S. (Ed.), & Harvey, M. (Ed.) (2015). The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield. In Katherine Mansfield and Literary Influence (pp. 207-218). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Wilson, Janet M ; Ailwood, Sarah (Editor) ; Harvey, Melinda (Editor). / The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield. Katherine Mansfield and Literary Influence. Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press, 2015. pp. 207-218
@inbook{9f09bf00eea747dd80471d47aeefe05d,
title = "The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield",
abstract = "This essay is situated in relation to the critical commonplace that the contrasting literary modes and prose styles of Frank Sargeson and Katherine Mansfield -- of hard-edged realist writing and the miniaturist ‘subjectivist’ writing of impressionism -- laid the foundation for the two traditions in New Zealand prose. I suggest that significant similarities can be found in the writers' artistic orientation, traceable to their critique of colonial culture and society: namely, an aesthetics of fragmentation, resistance to normative gender constructions of colonial society and their use of symbolic modes of representation. Furthermore, I argue that Mansfield can be traced as an intertextual presence in Sargeson’s work, alongside an implied gendered critique of her female voice, values and attitudes, and that he developed his repertoire by adapting her techniques of impressionism and impersonation to his ambivalently gendered viewpoint in order to nuance masculine vulnerability and unrequited love. This specific influence of Mansfield upon Sargeson will be illustrated with reference to his story, ‘A Man and his Wife’ (1939), in which I suggest he surreptitiously draws on Mansfield’s last story, ‘The Canary’ (1923), ‘writing back’ in a rural colonial context and voice to her metropolitan discourse.",
keywords = "Katherine Mansfield, Frank Sargeson, New Zealand cultural nationalism, homophobic, intertextual, the feminine tradition, 'The Canary', 'A Man and his Wife'",
author = "Wilson, {Janet M} and Sarah Ailwood and Melinda Harvey",
year = "2015",
month = "6",
day = "22",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780748694419",
pages = "207--218",
booktitle = "Katherine Mansfield and Literary Influence",
publisher = "Edinburgh University Press",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Wilson, JM, Ailwood, S (ed.) & Harvey, M (ed.) 2015, The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield. in Katherine Mansfield and Literary Influence. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, pp. 207-218.

The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield. / Wilson, Janet M; Ailwood, Sarah (Editor); Harvey, Melinda (Editor).

Katherine Mansfield and Literary Influence. Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press, 2015. p. 207-218.

Research output: Contribution to Book/Report typesChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield

AU - Wilson, Janet M

A2 - Ailwood, Sarah

A2 - Harvey, Melinda

PY - 2015/6/22

Y1 - 2015/6/22

N2 - This essay is situated in relation to the critical commonplace that the contrasting literary modes and prose styles of Frank Sargeson and Katherine Mansfield -- of hard-edged realist writing and the miniaturist ‘subjectivist’ writing of impressionism -- laid the foundation for the two traditions in New Zealand prose. I suggest that significant similarities can be found in the writers' artistic orientation, traceable to their critique of colonial culture and society: namely, an aesthetics of fragmentation, resistance to normative gender constructions of colonial society and their use of symbolic modes of representation. Furthermore, I argue that Mansfield can be traced as an intertextual presence in Sargeson’s work, alongside an implied gendered critique of her female voice, values and attitudes, and that he developed his repertoire by adapting her techniques of impressionism and impersonation to his ambivalently gendered viewpoint in order to nuance masculine vulnerability and unrequited love. This specific influence of Mansfield upon Sargeson will be illustrated with reference to his story, ‘A Man and his Wife’ (1939), in which I suggest he surreptitiously draws on Mansfield’s last story, ‘The Canary’ (1923), ‘writing back’ in a rural colonial context and voice to her metropolitan discourse.

AB - This essay is situated in relation to the critical commonplace that the contrasting literary modes and prose styles of Frank Sargeson and Katherine Mansfield -- of hard-edged realist writing and the miniaturist ‘subjectivist’ writing of impressionism -- laid the foundation for the two traditions in New Zealand prose. I suggest that significant similarities can be found in the writers' artistic orientation, traceable to their critique of colonial culture and society: namely, an aesthetics of fragmentation, resistance to normative gender constructions of colonial society and their use of symbolic modes of representation. Furthermore, I argue that Mansfield can be traced as an intertextual presence in Sargeson’s work, alongside an implied gendered critique of her female voice, values and attitudes, and that he developed his repertoire by adapting her techniques of impressionism and impersonation to his ambivalently gendered viewpoint in order to nuance masculine vulnerability and unrequited love. This specific influence of Mansfield upon Sargeson will be illustrated with reference to his story, ‘A Man and his Wife’ (1939), in which I suggest he surreptitiously draws on Mansfield’s last story, ‘The Canary’ (1923), ‘writing back’ in a rural colonial context and voice to her metropolitan discourse.

KW - Katherine Mansfield

KW - Frank Sargeson

KW - New Zealand cultural nationalism

KW - homophobic

KW - intertextual

KW - the feminine tradition

KW - 'The Canary'

KW - 'A Man and his Wife'

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780748694419

SP - 207

EP - 218

BT - Katherine Mansfield and Literary Influence

PB - Edinburgh University Press

CY - Edinburgh

ER -

Wilson JM, Ailwood S, (ed.), Harvey M, (ed.). The 'Burden' of the feminine: Frank Sargeson's encounter with Katherine Mansfield. In Katherine Mansfield and Literary Influence. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 2015. p. 207-218