What role does gender have in shaping knowledge that underpins the practice of midwifery?

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticle

Abstract

Midwifery is an ancient profession that continues to be practiced almost exclusively by women. This paper explores the role that millennia of gender exclusivity has had in shaping the knowledge that informs the profession. Prior to the Renaissance this knowledge was exclusively female, largely oral, tacit and intuitive whilst recognising childbearing as an important transformative period in a woman’s lifecycle. Male scientific enquiry in the seventeenth century into human anatomy extended to women’s bodies and childbirth and disrupted the female ways of knowing. Their positivist ontology focussing on the mechanics of childbirth created an opportunity for intervening in a normal process and receiving payment for it. The perceived structural superiority of a male obstetric ontology of childbirth has posed an existential threat to the midwifery profession. This paper concludes by discussing how 20th century professional regulation of midwifery has encouraged midwives to use patriarchal structures and frameworks of knowledge to co-exist within the hegemonic biomedical model advocated by the majority of their obstetric colleagues.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)629-634
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Gender Studies
Volume28
Issue number6
Early online date21 Mar 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 21 Mar 2019

Fingerprint

obstetrics
profession
ontology
gender
midwife
Renaissance
seventeenth century
mechanic
threat
regulation
Midwifery
Childbirth
Obstetrics
Ontology
Positivist
Midwives
Superiority
Threat
Millennium
Exclusivity

Keywords

  • Midwifery
  • epistemology
  • expert opinion
  • intuition
  • knowledge
  • obstetrics
  • ontology
  • profession

Cite this

@article{986757b02e484cf1a0c6061e61bd7b9b,
title = "What role does gender have in shaping knowledge that underpins the practice of midwifery?",
abstract = "Midwifery is an ancient profession that continues to be practiced almost exclusively by women. This paper explores the role that millennia of gender exclusivity has had in shaping the knowledge that informs the profession. Prior to the Renaissance this knowledge was exclusively female, largely oral, tacit and intuitive whilst recognising childbearing as an important transformative period in a woman’s lifecycle. Male scientific enquiry in the seventeenth century into human anatomy extended to women’s bodies and childbirth and disrupted the female ways of knowing. Their positivist ontology focussing on the mechanics of childbirth created an opportunity for intervening in a normal process and receiving payment for it. The perceived structural superiority of a male obstetric ontology of childbirth has posed an existential threat to the midwifery profession. This paper concludes by discussing how 20th century professional regulation of midwifery has encouraged midwives to use patriarchal structures and frameworks of knowledge to co-exist within the hegemonic biomedical model advocated by the majority of their obstetric colleagues.",
keywords = "Midwifery, epistemology, expert opinion, intuition, knowledge, obstetrics, ontology, profession",
author = "John Pendleton",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
day = "21",
doi = "10.1080/09589236.2019.1590185",
language = "English",
volume = "28",
pages = "629--634",
journal = "Journal of Gender Studies",
issn = "0958-9236",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "6",

}

What role does gender have in shaping knowledge that underpins the practice of midwifery? / Pendleton, John.

In: Journal of Gender Studies, Vol. 28, No. 6, 21.03.2019, p. 629-634.

Research output: Contribution to JournalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - What role does gender have in shaping knowledge that underpins the practice of midwifery?

AU - Pendleton, John

PY - 2019/3/21

Y1 - 2019/3/21

N2 - Midwifery is an ancient profession that continues to be practiced almost exclusively by women. This paper explores the role that millennia of gender exclusivity has had in shaping the knowledge that informs the profession. Prior to the Renaissance this knowledge was exclusively female, largely oral, tacit and intuitive whilst recognising childbearing as an important transformative period in a woman’s lifecycle. Male scientific enquiry in the seventeenth century into human anatomy extended to women’s bodies and childbirth and disrupted the female ways of knowing. Their positivist ontology focussing on the mechanics of childbirth created an opportunity for intervening in a normal process and receiving payment for it. The perceived structural superiority of a male obstetric ontology of childbirth has posed an existential threat to the midwifery profession. This paper concludes by discussing how 20th century professional regulation of midwifery has encouraged midwives to use patriarchal structures and frameworks of knowledge to co-exist within the hegemonic biomedical model advocated by the majority of their obstetric colleagues.

AB - Midwifery is an ancient profession that continues to be practiced almost exclusively by women. This paper explores the role that millennia of gender exclusivity has had in shaping the knowledge that informs the profession. Prior to the Renaissance this knowledge was exclusively female, largely oral, tacit and intuitive whilst recognising childbearing as an important transformative period in a woman’s lifecycle. Male scientific enquiry in the seventeenth century into human anatomy extended to women’s bodies and childbirth and disrupted the female ways of knowing. Their positivist ontology focussing on the mechanics of childbirth created an opportunity for intervening in a normal process and receiving payment for it. The perceived structural superiority of a male obstetric ontology of childbirth has posed an existential threat to the midwifery profession. This paper concludes by discussing how 20th century professional regulation of midwifery has encouraged midwives to use patriarchal structures and frameworks of knowledge to co-exist within the hegemonic biomedical model advocated by the majority of their obstetric colleagues.

KW - Midwifery

KW - epistemology

KW - expert opinion

KW - intuition

KW - knowledge

KW - obstetrics

KW - ontology

KW - profession

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/role-gender-shaping-knowledge-underpins-practice-midwifery

U2 - 10.1080/09589236.2019.1590185

DO - 10.1080/09589236.2019.1590185

M3 - Article

VL - 28

SP - 629

EP - 634

JO - Journal of Gender Studies

JF - Journal of Gender Studies

SN - 0958-9236

IS - 6

ER -