Fitting the profile: Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble

Lorna Jowett, Nicholas Ray (Editor)

Research output: Contribution to Book/ReportChapter

Abstract

Watching The Shield for the first time as a fan of The X-Files, it is immediately striking that detective Holland ‘Dutch’ Wagenbach is like a parallel Fox Mulder. But while Mulder was a hero in a two-character show that blended genres and had a fantastic premise, Dutch is part of an ensemble of characters in a much more firmly-rooted genre show with an aesthetic of gritty realism. In the parallel televerse of The Shield, the intellectual with an interest in psychological profiling is not a clean-cut hotshot who resists the structures of the FBI from the inside, he is rumpled, ageing and part of a police team whose other members often ridicule him. This chapter explores how the realist aesthetic and the ensemble cast of The Shield work to position Dutch in particular ways but also add complexity to his character. The show is often about masculinities, and to succeed in negotiating this, it uses its ensemble cast to contrast different versions of masculinity and femininity, and the ways these are inflected by race, ethnicity, class and sexuality. As another anxious white male, Dutch is essential to presenting this complex web of representation.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationInterrogating The Shield
Place of PublicationSyracuse, New York
PublisherSyracuse University Press
Chapter4
Pages65-86
Number of pages227
ISBN (Print)9780815633082
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2012

Publication series

NameTelevision and popular culture

Fingerprint

Realism
Ensemble
Shield
Aesthetics
Masculinity
Ridicule
Police
Hero
Ethnic Groups
Femininity
File
Detectives
Cut
Psychological
Profiling
World Wide Web
Sexuality
Realist

Keywords

  • television
  • crime drama
  • masculinity
  • gender
  • representation
  • aesthetics
  • The Shield
  • The X-Files

Cite this

Jowett, L., & Ray, N. (Ed.) (2012). Fitting the profile: Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble. In Interrogating The Shield (pp. 65-86). (Television and popular culture). Syracuse, New York: Syracuse University Press.
Jowett, Lorna ; Ray, Nicholas (Editor). / Fitting the profile: Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble. Interrogating The Shield. Syracuse, New York : Syracuse University Press, 2012. pp. 65-86 (Television and popular culture).
@inbook{4fa1b69307da4d56a57ce65fb5addb9d,
title = "Fitting the profile:: Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble",
abstract = "Watching The Shield for the first time as a fan of The X-Files, it is immediately striking that detective Holland ‘Dutch’ Wagenbach is like a parallel Fox Mulder. But while Mulder was a hero in a two-character show that blended genres and had a fantastic premise, Dutch is part of an ensemble of characters in a much more firmly-rooted genre show with an aesthetic of gritty realism. In the parallel televerse of The Shield, the intellectual with an interest in psychological profiling is not a clean-cut hotshot who resists the structures of the FBI from the inside, he is rumpled, ageing and part of a police team whose other members often ridicule him. This chapter explores how the realist aesthetic and the ensemble cast of The Shield work to position Dutch in particular ways but also add complexity to his character. The show is often about masculinities, and to succeed in negotiating this, it uses its ensemble cast to contrast different versions of masculinity and femininity, and the ways these are inflected by race, ethnicity, class and sexuality. As another anxious white male, Dutch is essential to presenting this complex web of representation.",
keywords = "television, crime drama, masculinity, gender, representation, aesthetics, The Shield, The X-Files",
author = "Lorna Jowett and Nicholas Ray",
year = "2012",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780815633082",
series = "Television and popular culture",
publisher = "Syracuse University Press",
pages = "65--86",
booktitle = "Interrogating The Shield",

}

Jowett, L & Ray, N (ed.) 2012, Fitting the profile: Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble. in Interrogating The Shield. Television and popular culture, Syracuse University Press, Syracuse, New York, pp. 65-86.

Fitting the profile: Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble. / Jowett, Lorna; Ray, Nicholas (Editor).

Interrogating The Shield. Syracuse, New York : Syracuse University Press, 2012. p. 65-86 (Television and popular culture).

Research output: Contribution to Book/ReportChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Fitting the profile:

T2 - Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble

AU - Jowett, Lorna

A2 - Ray, Nicholas

PY - 2012/1/1

Y1 - 2012/1/1

N2 - Watching The Shield for the first time as a fan of The X-Files, it is immediately striking that detective Holland ‘Dutch’ Wagenbach is like a parallel Fox Mulder. But while Mulder was a hero in a two-character show that blended genres and had a fantastic premise, Dutch is part of an ensemble of characters in a much more firmly-rooted genre show with an aesthetic of gritty realism. In the parallel televerse of The Shield, the intellectual with an interest in psychological profiling is not a clean-cut hotshot who resists the structures of the FBI from the inside, he is rumpled, ageing and part of a police team whose other members often ridicule him. This chapter explores how the realist aesthetic and the ensemble cast of The Shield work to position Dutch in particular ways but also add complexity to his character. The show is often about masculinities, and to succeed in negotiating this, it uses its ensemble cast to contrast different versions of masculinity and femininity, and the ways these are inflected by race, ethnicity, class and sexuality. As another anxious white male, Dutch is essential to presenting this complex web of representation.

AB - Watching The Shield for the first time as a fan of The X-Files, it is immediately striking that detective Holland ‘Dutch’ Wagenbach is like a parallel Fox Mulder. But while Mulder was a hero in a two-character show that blended genres and had a fantastic premise, Dutch is part of an ensemble of characters in a much more firmly-rooted genre show with an aesthetic of gritty realism. In the parallel televerse of The Shield, the intellectual with an interest in psychological profiling is not a clean-cut hotshot who resists the structures of the FBI from the inside, he is rumpled, ageing and part of a police team whose other members often ridicule him. This chapter explores how the realist aesthetic and the ensemble cast of The Shield work to position Dutch in particular ways but also add complexity to his character. The show is often about masculinities, and to succeed in negotiating this, it uses its ensemble cast to contrast different versions of masculinity and femininity, and the ways these are inflected by race, ethnicity, class and sexuality. As another anxious white male, Dutch is essential to presenting this complex web of representation.

KW - television

KW - crime drama

KW - masculinity

KW - gender

KW - representation

KW - aesthetics

KW - The Shield

KW - The X-Files

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780815633082

T3 - Television and popular culture

SP - 65

EP - 86

BT - Interrogating The Shield

PB - Syracuse University Press

CY - Syracuse, New York

ER -

Jowett L, Ray N, (ed.). Fitting the profile: Dutch Wagenbach, realism, and the ensemble. In Interrogating The Shield. Syracuse, New York: Syracuse University Press. 2012. p. 65-86. (Television and popular culture).